by Liza Cirolia
Utopian thinking, defined by Friedman as “the capacity to imagine a future that departs significantly from what we know to be a general condition in the present” has informed a range of social and ideological movements from the Paris Commune to the Zapatistas of South-eastern Mexico (in Swilling et al, 2010; Harvey, 2012).
Pieterse writes “[t]he existential core of urbanism is the desire for radical change to bring all the good implied in the original utopian association of ‘the city’” (2008, 6).
Over the decades, the disciplines of planning and architecture have remained fixated with the possibility of anthropogenic urban utopias. Following the Garden Cities Movement, wherein pockets of self-sustaining communities attempted to knit themselves into a concentric puzzle of decentralised spatial governance, utopian design and, by extension governance, resonated deeply with modernism planners and architects who tirelessly search for answered to the perpetual urban crises. In retrospect, much of Le Corbusier and the other designers of his day, appeared to design the opposite of their espoused intentions of integration and justice (take for example the Opus Plan designed by Le Corbusier for Algiers which envisaged a gleaming ‘world capital of Africa’ wherein the rich and the poor would be segregated by a massive highway).
While hindsight may be 20/20, the adaptation of these visions echoes in today’s urban experiments. More recent African City Utopias include the Hope City on the outskirts of Accra, Eko Atlantic City in Lagos and Tatu City in Nairobi. On a smaller scale, gated communities, ‘lifestyle estates’, and urban villages create fortified utopian enclaves amidst the dystopian reality of Davis’s ‘Planet of the Slums’ (Macleod & Ward, 2002). These projects and others embody the optimism of the 2010 McKinsey and Co, report entitled “Lions on the move: The progress and potential of African economies”, sourcing global investment for ‘tech hubs’, ‘smart cities’, ‘Olympic villages’ and ‘satellite towns’.
While using ‘green’ and ‘brown’ language, these developments are frequently sites of social fragmentation and ‘splintered urbanism’. Lemanski writes “[p]rivate territories and gated communities in Southern cities are criticised for creating exclusionary spaces, increasing residential segregation, restricting freedom of movement, and exacerbating social divides” (Lemanski & Oldfield, 2009,1).
When we consider the future of urbanism of the African continent, we must carefully balance the often competing imperatives of attracting global capital by which to infuse the economy with the need to ensure that urban equality and citizenship is built into our dreams of better and more just cities.
Lemanski, C., & Oldfield, S. (2009). The parallel claims of gated communities and land invasions in a Southern city: polarised state responses. Environment and Planning A, 41(3), 634–648.
Harvey, D. (2012). Rebel cities: From the right to the city to the urban revolution. Verso Books.
Macleod, G., & Ward, K. (2002). Spaces of Utopia and Dystopia, Geografiska Annaler 84 B(3–4) .
Pieterse, E. (2008). City futures: confronting the crisis of urban development. Zed Books London.
This article originally appeared at Urban Africa on 30 July 2013.
‘Liza Cirolia is a researcher based in Cape Town. She is the researcher and co-ordinator of the Sustainable Human Settlements CityLab at the African Centre for Cities and has worked on a variety of research projects pertaining to urban citizenship, rights, and housing delivery.’
Latest posts by FutureLagos (see all)
- Voices of the City: Funke Makinwa | FUTURE LAGOS – February 9, 2016
- FUTURE LAGOS | Why a Lagos high street is booming : The changing face of Admiralty Way – November 26, 2015
- FUTURE LAGOS | Voices of the City: Mojisola Adegbile – November 20, 2015
- FUTURE LAGOS | Lagos Rising: From A City at Work Emerges a City of Creativity – October 29, 2015
- FUTURE LAGOS | Voices of the City: Mark Slade – October 23, 2015